Tiger Butter Fudge Recipe Easy (2024)

If you are looking for an easy candy to make for Christmas, wait until you try this tiger butter fudge recipe that’s super easy to make! Simply mix some peanut butter with chocolate to make this sweet treat the whole family will love.

I love a good recipe that whips up easily and tastes like it was professionally prepared.

And this recipe for tiger butter fudge homemade hits the mark!

You can make it in minutes and it is a serious crowd-pleaser.

I remember one of my friends’ moms making this recipe way back when I was in high school and I was hooked from the moment she sliced up some bars.

She used to make Christmas cookies for like 2 weeks straight making a different batch every day and tiger butter fudge was one of them.

You can’t beat the creamy combination of peanut butter with both white and semi-sweet chocolate chips.

It is a decadent and fun recipe to make that is perfect for the holidays because when you’re done? The fudge almost looks like it has tiger stripes.

I know a lot of people tend toward making peppermint bark for the holidays. But to me, there’s nothing quite like chocolate and peanut butter.

Am I right?

Wait until you see how easy and delicious this recipe is to make. And be sure to check out the rest of the holiday sweet treats at the end of this post.

(Posts on stacyling.com may contain affiliate links. Click HERE for full disclosure.)

Holiday Cookies and Sweet Treat Blog Hop

Thanks to my good friend Jen from Midwest Life and Style for pulling together such a beautiful group of talented bloggers with the most incredible holiday sweet treat inspiration. If you are coming from Nicolle’s from Our Tiny Nest, welcome!

If you are new here, I’m Stacy, a self-taught master gardener who lives and gardens in northern New Jersey, zone 6a.

We recently moved to a beautiful 1850 Farmhouse with 10 acres of gardens, sculptures, and statues.

I’ve been gardening for over 20 years and enjoy helping beginner gardeners find their inner green thumb, as well as discover a love for all things plants and flowers. I love to bring the outdoors inside my home too.

But I’m also a MAJOR foodie who loves to cook and entertain. So you’ll find a lot of quick, easy, and delicious recipe ideas that you can whip up in a snap.

Like this festive cranberry crockpot pork loin that takes minutes to prepare but tastes so good.

And my favorite artichoke dip and this quick and easy proscuitto and brie appetizer works well for the holidays too.

I hope you enjoy visiting my home today and hope you come back so we can grow stuff and create beautiful spaces together.

What is Tiger Butter Fudge Made Of?

What I love most about this recipe is the simplicity! Because there are only three ingredients.

Isn’t that the best?

The creamy combination of white and semi-sweet chocolate chips with peanut butter whips up pretty quickly to make this crazy good homemade dessert that your family and friends will rave about.

Which makes it a simple dish to make for the holidays or really any time of year. But I prefer to make it more around the holidays because it’s a great dish for cookie exchanges, small holiday gifts, and to share at Christmas parties.

When you are finished making tiger butter fudge, both chocolates create a marbelized design that looks a little like tiger stripes.

How Long Does Tiger Butter Last in the Fridge?

This tiger butter fudge recipe should last about 2-3 weeks in the refrigerator.

That is if you can avoid eating it all before then! LOL!

It is so good, I doubt you’ll need the 2-3 weeks in the fridge, but if you are planning when the best time to make it before Christmas, you’ll want to give yourself no more than 2-3 weeks.

How to Make Tiger Butter Fudge Recipe Easy

Because you pretty much just melt the chocolates with peanut butter and mix it together, this recipe for tiger butter fudge homemade is pretty simple to make!

And it is SO GOOD too. Holy fudgey goodness!

Wait until you try this super simple and easy dessert that’s perfect to make for a Christmas cookie exchange, a holiday dessert, or anytime during the year.

Ingredients and Supplies Needed To Make Tiger Butter Homemade Fudge

While this recipe for tiger butter fudge only has 3 ingredients, there are a few supplies you’ll need to make it.

Here’s what you need.

• 2 medium-sized mixing bowls
• Spatula
• Icing knife
• Microwave
• White chocolate chips
• Semi-sweet chocolate chips
• Creamy peanut butter
• 12″x9″ casserole dish
• Aluminum foil or parchment paper
• Non-stick cooking spray

Directions to Make Tiger Butter Homemade Fudge

It’s pretty simple to make tiger butter fudge.

But the best part?

It takes minutes to make. Here’s what you need to do.

• Melt white chocolate chips in a medium-sized mixing bowl in the microwave for about a minute. If it’s not melted enough to mix, put it back in the microwave for another 10 seconds and check it again.
• When the white chocolate is melted, fold in the peanut butter and mix well until thoroughly combined.
• Pour this mixture into a casserole dish covered with aluminum foil that has been greased.
• In a medium-sized mixing bowl, melt semi-sweet chocolate chips in the microwave for about a minute.
• Stir the chips until they are melted and then immediately pour over the white chocolate and peanut butter mixture.
• To get the marbelized look, take a knife and run it gently through the fudge.
• Refrigerate for a few hours until the fudge sets.
• Cut, serve and enjoy!

That’s it!

Doesn’t that sound so easy to make?

Next up on the Holiday Cookie and Sweet Treat Blog hop is my good friend Kelly from the Tattered Pew. Wait until you try her dad’s molasses cookie recipe! Yum yum!

And… If you’re catching up on blog posts you may have missed, be sure to sign-up to get my newest posts via email to stay up to date with everything that’s happening here on the blog and more.

Christmas Cookies and Holiday Treats

Are you looking to add some new recipes to your holiday rotation this year? Click on the links below to go to each post and see more.

The Tattered Pew – Daddy’s Molasses Cookies | Open Doors Open Hearts – Cinnamon Sugar Pecans | WM Design House – Cinnamon Popcorn | She Gave It A Go – Holiday Punch

Want More Holiday Food and Drink Ideas?

Check out these posts.

• 9 Popular Christmas Cookie and Sweet Treat Recipes You Should Try
• Easy Christmas Cookies
• The Best Crockpot Cranberry Pork Loin
• Family Breakfast and Brunch Recipes for Christmas
• The Ultimate Dip of Spinach Artichoke Recipes
• 6 Delicious New Year’s Eve Food Ideas
• Quick and Easy Proscuitto Recipe Appetizer
• How to Host a Christmas Clambake

Sign Me Up!

Sign up for my free newsletter to get blog posts, seasonal tips, recipes, and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Plus, get free VIP access to my Resource Library where you’ll find insider freebies not readily available to the public.

Pin It to Save It For Later

Thank you so much for following along.

Enjoy a beautiful day! xo

About Me

Want to learn more about me?

Get the inside scoop about my background, education, and experience, as well as why I started blogging.

Let’s Connect!

If you like this post, please follow me @bricksnblooms on Pinterest, Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok. Subscribe to my YouTube Channel. Or join my Facebook Group.